Play Brightcove video
A farmer from Lampeter has known as on the Welsh Authorities to rethink new guidelines on agricultural air pollution.
Andrew Jones, 66, has been farming close to the Teifi river for almost half a century. Now, he says the fee to adjust to the brand new laws is “simply not value it.”
“Between all the pieces, I concern it’ll price me at the least £100,000. I’d surrender farming, however due to my son, I’m sticking at it. I would like him to have a chance to farm right here too.”
“My mates have all retired, however now I’ve this added burden,” he instructed Dot Davies on S4C’s flagship present affairs programme, Y Byd ar Bedwar.
“You’re feeling the stress, you possibly can’t sleep… it’s a relentless fear.”
In January this 12 months, the Welsh Authorities introduced that the entire of Wales would develop into a ‘Nitrate Susceptible Zone’, or NVZ – an space the place water is in danger from nitrate air pollution, primarily attributable to agricultural slurry and fertiliser. The goal of the laws are to deal with agricultural air pollution incidents – which in accordance with the Welsh Authorities stay very excessive, averaging over three per week within the final three years.
Y Byd ar Bedwar discovered that there have been almost 600 incidents of agricultural air pollution in Welsh rivers since 2017. Credit score: Y Byd ar Bedwar
The brand new guidelines, which got here into power on 1 April 2021, will probably be launched in phases over the following three years. The principles embody strict durations wherein spreading slurry is just not allowed, upgrading storage services to a capability of at the least 5 months, and protecting storage services to scale back the quantity of rain that may fall on high of the slurry, which will increase its quantity.
Andrew feels these adjustments are “far too strict.” He’s calling on the Minister for Rural Affairs, Lesley Griffiths, to “rethink, and use just a little extra frequent sense.”
“Lesley Griffiths promised to not change any laws throughout Covid. She’s been ruthless in introducing them now.”
“It’s about getting that stability and it is actually essential that we crack this,” says Minister for Rural Affairs, Lesley Griffiths. Credit score: Y Byd ar Bedwar
In response, Lesley Griffiths stated that the choice was “not ruthless in any respect. It took me 5 years.”
“Simply since this 12 months we’ve had 76 substantiated agricultural air pollution incidents, so even whereas it’s being talked about, we’re nonetheless sadly getting this variety of incidents. It’s about getting that stability and it is actually essential that we crack this.”
In a Freedom of Data request to Pure Sources Wales, the physique tasked with defending sources similar to rivers, Y Byd ar Bedwar discovered that there have been almost 600 incidents of agricultural air pollution in Welsh rivers since 2017. Almost half of those had been because of slurry.
The Freedom of Data request additionally discovered that Carmarthenshire was the world with the best variety of agricultural air pollution incidents in Wales during the last 4 years, with the world accounting for 20% of all instances in Wales.
The principles for farmers embody strict durations wherein spreading slurry is just not allowed and upgrading storage services. Credit score: Y Byd ar Bedwar
Andrew Jones added, “If these from Carmarthenshire had been really fined, then that would have solved the issue, as an alternative of constructing others like me, must pay the worth when there’s no want.”
Since 2017 there have been simply two prosecutions referring to agricultural air pollution in Welsh rivers. Pure Sources Wales took enforcement motion in an extra 27 instances, leading to cautions, warnings, civil sanctions, notices or the issuing of recommendation and steering. Two instances are nonetheless ongoing.
579 incidents of agricultural air pollution in Welsh rivers since 2017
In response, Lesley Griffiths stated “I believe it’s actually essential that enforcement takes place – clearly, Pure Sources Wales are the physique we glance to for enforcement. I believe actually we haven’t seen sufficient individuals prosecuted. Pure Sources Wales inform me they do as a lot enforcement as they’ll.”
In addition to the monetary pressure, Andrew, who has a dairy herd of 85 cows, is anxious concerning the psychological well being influence on farmers.
“I’ve sadly misplaced one buddy this 12 months – the burden was an excessive amount of for him. It’s no surprise that folks discuss farmers’ psychological well being and excessive suicide charges, as a result of it’s actual. And it is a huge blow.”
Andrew fears the repercussions of the brand new guidelines saying “household farms give stability to the countryside, to the business and to the language.”
Amongst people who have observed the impact of air pollution on rivers is former worldwide Welsh rugby participant and eager fisherman, Sir Gareth Edwards.
Gareth Edwards fishing together with his grandson. Credit score: Y Byd ar Bedwar
Gareth first picked up a rod when he was six years outdated, and since then he has traveled world wide fishing.
“It’s such a pleasure to exit, and never solely to catch the fish, however the feeling you get while you maintain the rod. You’ll be able to’t describe it… Your coronary heart goes loopy!”
The Freedom of Data request to NRW exhibits over the previous 4 years, there have been 35 incidents of agricultural air pollution on the river Tywi. Gareth says he has observed a change within the river.
We have now to attempt to get the state of the rivers again to what it was once. Sir Gareth Edwards
“I used to return right here and see fish like an oil slick – possibly 100 of them, and 100 sewin mendacity within the pool. It’s onerous to consider that right this moment, we’ve seen one or two.”
“There was once loads of fish to catch in rivers throughout Wales. Our nation was top-of-the-line for fish similar to bramble, sewin and salmon.”
“It’s not so good as it was, however we now have to attempt to get the state of the rivers again to what it was once.”
In keeping with Dylan Roberts, Head of Fisheries on the Recreation and Wildlife Conservation Belief, the state of rivers is “extraordinarily poor”.
“Vitamins from agriculture trigger issues like algae to develop unnaturally. That then suffocates the life within the river.”
“If you happen to return to the 70’s, 80’s and examine that to now, the variety of salmon and sewin that come into our rivers has fallen by round 70 – 80%.”
He stated that this has a knock on impact on the Welsh economic system too.
“Folks from all around the world would come fishing in Wales for sea trout. However with much less fish to catch, it has a huge impact on the native economic system as there’s no fish right here for them to catch.”
Final month, the Welsh Parliament voted for a evaluate of the brand new guidelines, and the brand new laws will probably be checked out once more by a committee of members.
A Welsh Authorities spokesperson stated: “It is going to be a matter for the committee to resolve what the evaluate will have a look at.”
“The main target should now be on implementation of the laws to deal with the unacceptable ranges of air pollution and we welcome discussions on successfully delivering this.”
In a press release, Pure Sources Wales stated they take their tasks for guaranteeing water high quality severely and this contains taking enforcement motion the place acceptable. They stated “regulation and enforcement are solely two parts wanted to deal with agricultural air pollution” and ought to be utilized in mixture with recommendation, steering, schooling and funding.
Watch Y Byd ar Bedwar at 8:25pm on Wednesday thirtieth June on S4C and iPlayer, with English subtitles out there.
